Ask a group of managers whether they mentor their direct reports and most will say yes. Ask the reports whether they can speak freely, and the room goes quiet.
Mentoring runs on candour about doubt, ambition and mistakes — the material people withhold from whoever signs off their rating. A manager can coach in the flow of work, but once the same relationship carries appraisal, pay and promotion, the conversation narrows to what is safe to say.
This is a design problem, not a character flaw. L&D managers building mentoring schemes should place career mentoring outside the reporting line, and say out loud which hat is on when it cannot be. HR leaders can make cross-functional mentoring a legitimate route rather than a workaround. Trainers can teach managers to ask before advising. Instructional designers rarely touch this, yet no curriculum fixes confidentiality that is not real.
Coaching inside the hierarchy is possible. Candour inside it needs a boundary drawn out loud.
Comments 0
Sign in to like, save or comment.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.