Coaching asks people to think out loud about what they don't yet know. Appraisal asks a manager to judge what they have delivered. When one person does both, the coachee learns quickly which version of the truth is safe to say.
Nothing in the coaching literature assumes the coach also holds the rating. That is an organisational design choice, and it carries a cost: honesty. A manager who has just heard "I'm not sure I can handle this account" cannot easily unhear it when writing the review.
What helps is not abandoning manager-coaching but separating it. Name the hat at the start of the conversation. Keep development notes out of the rating record unless the person agrees. Move formal appraisal to a different point in the calendar rather than back-to-back with a coaching session.
For trainers, the implication is design: don't teach coaching skills inside the appraisal workshop and expect both to survive. For HR leaders, it is policy: decide explicitly where confidential coaching ends.
Which hat is your organisation asking managers to wear, and have you told them?
Comments 0
Sign in to like, save or comment.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.