Most training shows people what experts do. Very little of it shows them how experts think.
Cognitive apprenticeship, developed by Collins, Brown and Newman, treats learning as enculturation into expert practice. It rests on six methods: modelling (an expert makes their reasoning audible), coaching (observation plus targeted feedback), scaffolding (support that fades), articulation (learners name their reasoning), reflection (comparing their process with an expert's) and exploration (tackling new problems alone).
Why it matters: tacit judgement is the part of expertise that never makes it into a slide deck. When a subject matter expert writes content instead of demonstrating reasoning, learners inherit the vocabulary and not the judgement.
In practice:
- Trainers narrate decisions live rather than summarising them afterwards.
- Instructional designers build in articulation prompts, not only quizzes.
- L&D managers recruit experts for coaching hours, not just content review.
- HR leaders treat expertise-sharing as real work, not overhead.
Which of your experts could be observed rather than merely interviewed?