Ask a group which version of a course they preferred and they will pick the smooth one: clean slides, instant answers, no struggle. Ask them a month later what they can still do, and the ranking often flips.
Robert Bjork's work on desirable difficulties makes the point plainly. Conditions that slow learning down, such as retrieval practice, spacing, interleaving, and generating an answer before being told it, tend to depress performance during training while improving retention afterwards. Fluency in the room is a poor proxy for learning.
This matters because L&D is still often judged on the in-room experience. Smoother feels like better.
The implications differ by role. Trainers need to normalise productive struggle and explain to participants why it is happening. Instructional designers should build retrieval and spacing into the structure, rather than bolting a quiz onto the end. L&D managers should shield designers from feedback that equates ease with quality. HR leaders can shift evaluation from end-of-session ratings towards delayed capability checks.
The question worth asking: is your programme designed to be enjoyed, or to be remembered?