A manager asks for a short quiz at the end of a course. The trainer writes twenty questions that check whether people remember the slides. Everyone passes. Three weeks later, the same errors appear on the floor.
Nothing failed. The assessment measured the wrong thing. A quiz that asks learners to recall a definition confirms attendance, not capability. If the job requires judgement under pressure, the assessment should ask for a judgement, with a realistic scenario and plausible distractors.
Three questions worth asking before writing any item:
- What decision will this person make at work?
- What would a wrong answer look like there?
- Does this item separate the skilled from the merely present?
The role differs. A trainer can rewrite items in the room; an instructional designer builds scenarios into the flow; an L&D manager defends the design time with the business case; an HR leader asks whether the assessment predicts performance, not completion.
If nobody could fail your assessment, it isn't an assessment.