Myth: reaction data is worthless because learners rate the biscuits, not the learning.
Reality: the problem is rarely the level. It is the question. Ask whether the session was enjoyable and you have measured hospitality. Ask whether the content was relevant to the work, whether the learner could explain it to a colleague, and whether they know what they will do differently on Monday, and the same form becomes an early signal of transfer.
Kirkpatrick never claimed reaction predicted results. He claimed that learners who see no relevance are unlikely to try anything. That is a modest, testable proposition, and it is the one most evaluation arguments skip past.
Trainers can rewrite two questions tomorrow. Instructional designers should read low relevance scores as a design brief, not a popularity contest. L&D managers should report reaction alongside application evidence, never instead of it. HR leaders should stop asking for one number that proves value.
What does your form actually ask?
Comments 0
Sign in to like, save or comment.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.