Job tenure is a poor proxy for expertise. Ask any team that promoted on years served, then wondered why nothing changed.
Research on expert performance keeps returning to one conclusion: what separates experts from experienced non-experts is not time on task but the quality of practice. Effortful work on current weaknesses, feedback close to the moment of performance, repeated correction. Experience alone automates whatever people already do, including their mistakes. Ten years of unexamined repetition can produce one year of learning, repeated ten times.
That matters because L&D still counts exposure as evidence: hours, completions, years in role. None of it shows that judgement improved.
- Trainers: trade content for practice that surfaces errors.
- Instructional designers: build feedback loops and rising difficulty into the flow, not into a final assessment.
- L&D managers and HR leaders: base readiness decisions on observed capability, not tenure.
What in your programme deliberately asks people to practise the thing they are worst at?
Comments 0
Sign in to like, save or comment.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.