Most change work starts with a gap analysis: find the deficit, close it. Appreciative inquiry starts the other way round — find what already works at its best, and amplify it. Both are legitimate OD approaches, and they answer different questions.
Deficit-based diagnosis is strong on risk, compliance and known failure. It is weak at generating commitment, because it hands people a list of their shortcomings. Strength-based inquiry builds energy and ownership, but drifts into cheerleading if it never names what is actually failing.
The practical answer is sequence, not allegiance. Ask what is working and why, then ask what is not, then decide which question this situation deserves.
A trainer feels this in needs analysis; an instructional designer in whose real examples get used; an L&D manager in which interventions get funded; an HR leader in how the diagnosis is framed publicly.
Which question does your organisation ask first?
Comments 0
Sign in to like, save or comment.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.